Aerogarden vs Click and Grow

Hi! Are you too busy to tend to an outdoor garden’s needs but still want to enjoy the fruits and vegetables of one? Indoor smart gardening is the new trend that allows you to plant and grow various plants right in your home. These automated systems deliver nutrients, light, and even water to your crops, ensuring they are in excellent conditions to grow and flourish each time. 

While you may have no experience with these two systems, we can assist you in learning. To aid your decision-making process, we have pulled together this detailed review comparing the Aerogarden vs Click and Grow 3, highlighting what each brand has to offer. In this review, you are provided with all the necessary information to help with your efficient gardening journey. 

Comparison

Both systems are great options for growing plants, flowers, or crops. However, they are similar and different in various ways. Let us explore their features in this quick comparison so that you can examine the effectiveness of each system.

Aerogarden Benefits

  • It works with seed kits 
  • It is low maintenance 
  • It does not attract the regular garden pests or harbor diseases 
  • Can grow up to 12 pods of flowers, plants, or produce
  • It is aeroponic (does not require any dirt)
  • It is available in different shapes and sizes 
  • Ideal for small indoor spaces

Click and Grow 3 Benefits

  • It very easy to use 
  • It has a great design
  • Uses pre-seeded biodegradable pods
  • Uses Smart soil technology 
  • Available in different colors 
  • The main components comprise natural, renewable materials
  • It has a three-plant pod capacity 

What is an Aerogarden?

An Aerogarden is a new type of indoor system that is dirt-free and air-based. It allows plants to grow by putting the roots into water rich in nutrients. The system is a perfect substitute for small spaces with a comprehensive kit of 12 different types of plants that can be used throughout the year. 

It is very user-friendly, and you can become an expert gardener with this unit, as the Aerogarden can ensure your plants are green and healthier. You receive notifications whenever it is time for water and nutrients to be added. 

What is the Click and Grow Garden?

The Click and Grow Garden is a smart herb garden that combines technology and nature, allowing anyone to grow various plants, vegetables, flowers, and herbs with ease at home. This herb gardening kit uses hydroponic cultivation methods to make gardening enjoyable and is ideal for beginners.   

This system is a small unit with a LED light and watering system that uses smart soil in plant pods. Its sleek design and size make it easy to store and produce over 40 different types of plant pods. All you need to do is fill up the integrated water tank and adjust the lighting every few weeks, and you can have fruitful vegetation.

Stand out features

  • Click and Grow uses smart soil, allowing water to be evenly distributed in the pod, ensuring the roots always have water. The soil is patented with a nano-tech growth medium that contains zero hormones, fungicides, or harmful substances. It instead monitors the pH-level, oxygen, and nutrients, releasing minerals based on the temperature and moisture in the soil. This ensures plants grow to their fullest potential, bearing healthy, nutritious produce that is ready to eat. 
  • The built-in water tank ensures your plants are taken care of even if you decide to take a vacation, as the water reservoir holds enough water to last 2-3 weeks. 
  • Both systems are great opportunities for teaching and exploration for the family, especially children.

Pros and Cons of Each Product

Aerogarden

Pros

  • Your garden is free from pests, rodents, worms, slugs, snails, and any other insects that hang around plants, which is ideal if you subscribe to the belief in fresh food items, ready to transfer from the garden to the pot. This also means you never have to use insecticides or pesticides on your plants. 
  • The built-in control panel allows for manual growth settings. This level of control allows you to manage the entire growth process, so you can sow seeds and make the environment more conducive to growth.  
  • A continuous stock of flowers and produce is at your fingertips. The ecosystem can support several plants because a few weeks after planting, your produce is ready for harvesting. 
  • Due to the rapid growth feature, you can experiment with hybrid produce. Since you no longer have a long wait period to test your crops’ success. The Aerogarden allows you to grow all kinds of custom plants.
  • It has an advanced watering system that has great circulation to keep everything fresh.
  • The Aerogarden has variable height adjustments to accommodate taller flowers and plants.

What Are the Disadvantages of the Aerogarden, You May Ask?

  • The plants grown by the Aerogarden tend to have a different shape than those naturally grown. It is merely temporary, as with time, the plants begin to look normal. 
  • The watering pump constantly produces an annoying, humming sound, which dampens the experience if there is no designated area to accommodate the unit. 
  • Lacks an application for controlling production, the absence of a voice-activated interface takes away from the smart operation. 

What Advantages Are There in the Click and Grow? 

  • The Click and Grow Smart Garden has a great design. It looks attractive and is portable since it comes in different sizes and colors you can choose from. 
  • It is effortless to use, as all you need to do is add the pods, fill the tank with water, plug the garden in, and watch it do the rest.
  • It produces fresh and healthy plants. The nutrients level of herbs and vegetables are linked to their freshness, and you can cut the plant a second before putting it in the pot.
  • It is power efficient, so there won’t be much impact on your light bill as the Click and Grow 3 uses a total power of 8-Watts. 
  • The Click and Grow noiseless with no distracting sounds.

What Are the Disadvantages of the Click and Grow?

  • It is expensive. You can get an ordinary garden planter for half as much as the price for this indoor garden.
  • The produce yielded is very small. You may be disappointed if you purchase the system intending to feed your family, as the garden is suited for growing flowers, herbs, and garnishes. It takes weeks to grow plants large enough for harvesting and the low yield due to the size of the Click and Grow. 
  • The cost of the refill pods is relatively expensive as it works like a printer and ink situation. To reduce the cost, you can try reusing the pods with your personal growing seeds and medium. 
  • Plant growth height is limited. While the light has an extension, you may need to purchase an additional extension if you want your plants to grow tall. 
  • For experienced gardeners, there aren’t many overall options to explore.

Factors to Consider Before Choosing 

What Kind of Quantity Are You Looking to Work with?

While both units can grow different types of plants, the yield you expect is an important factor. The Aerogarden offers moderate supply with its continuous harvesting capabilities. The Click and Grow, on the other hand, does not, as its yield is small unless you’re looking for herbs and garnishes. 

Organic Growth

Quite a few people prefer to grow and eat more organic foods, that are less likely to be exposed to harmful gases and substances during growth. 

Consider What Savings Matter Most

The Click and Grow is a smaller system that is easy to construct and use but is expensive initially. However, the Aerogarden saves you more on your grocery bill as more produce can be grown. 

Click and Grow vs Aerogarden: The Winner

Now is the time to make the decision about which system you plan to implement.

We believe that the Aerogarden is the better option here as it is less expensive, a better value for money, and yields more produce. The Click and Grow is costly, and the number of pods is limited. 

Though both are suited for indoor gardening in small spaces for a healthier and hassle-free lifestyle, the Aerogarden has a longer list of advantages and produces more at a faster rate. It is not without its drawbacks, but the benefits outweigh them.  

While we give the win to the Aerogarden this time, here’s a reminder. The two were not necessarily intended for the same use. The Click and Grow are designed for small-scale vegetation and beginner familiarity. The Aerogarden is a good teaching tool too, but it’s not better in this regard. Still, this difference would explain the Click and Grow’s limited capabilities. 

While the Click and Grow uses smart technology and is more feasible for its intended purpose, the Aerogarden’s design and feature set make it a better purchase.